Murder Committed

Previous

Next

Home

Coiners Story
Coiners Homeland
The 'Royal' Family
Coiners Gang
Coiners Downfall
Murder Committed
Wanted Men

Hangman's Noose
Murderers Trial
Coiners End

History of the Guinea

Hartley Family History

Links

Guestbook

Contact Me

The arrest of David Hartley had the effect of poking a wasps nest with a stick and the coiners revenge would be swift. Within a month of Hartley’s arrest, the activities of Deighton, the exciseman would be brought to a gruesome end. First though, the coiners would attempt to secure the release of their leader from his prison.

Broadbent must have been bitter at being duped by Deighton and James Stansfield, another coiner who came upon a drunken Broadbent heard how the informant had been blackmailed by the exciseman. Stansfield persuaded a reluctant Broadbent to visit Isaac Hartley, David's brother. Despite Isaac’s understandable anger, Stansfield managed to persuade him that Broadbent now believed David was innocent and that he might be prepared to retract the statement made to the magistrate.

It was agreed they would travel together to York where they met with the prisoners whilst they exercised in the courtyard. With David Hartley's agreement a revised statement was given to the York Attorney clearing the two men of their crimes. Bail was not forthcoming though so Isaac and Broadbent reluctantly returned to Cragg Vale. With no further news on their return, Isaac Hartley convinced Broadbent to visit Mr Leedes, the magistrate and retract his original statement. This was done, but once again brought no success; the Magistrate was inclined to believe the original story. Hartley and Jagger would remain imprisoned until their trial, but still took an active role in plotting the events that followed.

Isaac Hartley held a meeting with the principal coiners at the Dusty Miller in Mytholmroyd.  There was no alternative but for Deighton to die, but to find men willing to carry out such a risky task would be difficult and they would expect to be paid highly.

The names of two men Matthew Normington and Robert Thomas, known to those present as being sufficiently desperate for the money, were put forward. Thomas Spencer sought out supporters willing to offer them 100 guineas to carry out their deed.

After a number of unsuccessful visits to Halifax in search of their prey, Normington and Thomas finally brought William Deightons life to an end. The exciseman was shot shortly before midnight on the 8th November 1769. His body was discovered shortly afterwards by his daughter Susannah, their servant, Mary Broadbent, and a neighbour, Joseph Gledhill. His body showed marks of being stamped upon after he'd been shot.

Whilst the brutal murder rid the coiners of Deighton, it had the opposite effect to that which the coiners hoped. Far from dissuading the authorities from delving further into the activities of the gang, the effect was a renewed determination to bring the forgers and murderers to justice.